top spots to eat near Buckeye Lake Ohio
Ohio,  Travel,  Weekend Trips

7 Top Restaurants Near Buckeye Lake

Spread the love

Nestled in the heart of Ohio, Buckeye Lake is not just a picturesque getaway but also a culinary paradise. From breweries to diners and wineries, this charming locale has an array of dining options that cater to diverse palates. In this blog, we will explore some of the best restaurants near Buckeye Lake, Ohio, that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

Craft Cocktails at Horvath's Harbor
Craft Cocktails at Horvath’s Harbor

Where is Buckeye Lake?

Buckeye Lake, Ohio, is a village in Fairfield and Licking counties in the U.S. state of Ohio. The village is named after Buckeye Lake, a large lake along which it is situated. Buckeye Lake first served as a feeder lake for Ohio’s canal system during the early 1800s. After the canal era, the parklands around Buckeye Lake began attracting tourists from the central Ohio region.

Overall, Buckeye Lake, Ohio, offers various outdoor recreational opportunities, a growing business community, and many attractions to explore. Whether you’re interested in boating, fishing, or simply enjoying the area’s natural beauty, Buckeye Lake has something to offer everyone.

Great restaurants near Buckeye Lake, Ohio
Great restaurants near Buckeye Lake, Ohio

Buckeye Lake is conveniently located directly off I-70, about a half hour east of Columbus.

Top Restaurants At Buckeye Lake

While there are plenty of fast food options near Buckeye Lake, we share a few of our favorite restaurants that offer great service, delicious food, and good times.

Top Restaurants near Buckeye Lake Ohio

Buckeye Lake Brewery

Calling all beer enthusiasts! Buckeye Lake Brewery is a must-visit spot for its delectable American cuisine and exceptional selection of beers. This brewery is revered for its selection of craft brews along with great food from the attached restaurant Chef Shack. Whether you’re in the mood for juicy burgers, mouthwatering wings, or fresh tacos, Buckeye Lake Brewery has something for everyone to enjoy.

Tip: I recommend getting a beer flight to try a variety of different flavors.

Address: 5176 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

Pizza Cottage

For those craving a slice of Italian heaven, Pizza Cottage is the go-to destination. This family-friendly pizza chain is known for its cheesy breadsticks, tasty wings, and, of course, its mouthwatering pizzas. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Pizza Cottage offers a delightful dining experience for families and friends. Don’t forget to save room for their delectable desserts aka dessert pizza!

The Pizza Cottage is perfect for carry-out or delivery and is conveniently located next to the Buckeye Lake KOA.

Address: 4592 Walnut Rd Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

Pappy D’s Island House

If you’re looking to enjoy a waterfront dining experience, Pappy D’s Island House is a perfect destination. Right near the waters of Buckeye Lake, this restaurant offers a menu that caters to seafood lovers. From fresh catches of the day to succulent shrimp dishes, their seafood specialties are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

Great spots to eat at near Buckeye Lake, Ohio
Great spots to eat at near Buckeye Lake, Ohio

With lakeside views, live music, and delicious cuisine, Pappy D’s Island House is a perfect spot to unwind and savor the lakeside atmosphere.

Grab a drink at Pappy D's
Tropical Drinks at Pappy D’s

Pappy D’s has boat docks so you can pull up your boat, grab a bite to eat, then head back to the lake!

Address: 2977 Greenlawn Ave NE, Millersport, OH, United States, Ohio

Our Lakeside Diner

For a classic All-American dining experience, look no further than Our Lakeside Diner. Known for its inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, this diner offers home-style cooking. Their breakfast options are particularly popular, with fluffy pancakes and hearty omelets being favorites among locals and tourists alike. Our Lakeside Diner is your typically greasy spoon diner, and the prices can’t be beat!

Address: 5276 Walnut Rd Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

Horvath’s Harbor

Situated right along the water, Horvath’s Harbor is a hidden gem that shouldn’t be missed. This family-owned cocktail tavern offers a diverse menu featuring upscale appetizers to seafood favorites. From Crispy Brussel Sprouts to Lobster Rolls Horvath’s Harbor takes pride in serving high-quality food paired with their unique cocktail creations. The outdoor firepits and spacious patio make dining here an unforgettable experience.

Appetizer sample at Horvath's Harbor
Appetizer sample at Horvath’s Harbor

Horvath’s Harbor will offer live entertainment throughout the week.

Address: 14675 Zion Road, Thornville, Ohio 43076, United States

Wheldon’s Ice Cream Factory

No culinary journey is complete without a sweet treat, and Wheldon’s Ice Cream Factory doesn’t disappoint. This charming ice cream parlor offers a wide variety of flavors, from classic favorites to unique creations. Whether you prefer a classic cone, a sumptuous sundae, or a delightful milkshake, Wheldon’s has you covered. Indulge in their creamy creations and treat yourself to a few tunes on their authentic jukebox!

Wheldon's Ice Cream Factory

Address: 2887 Canal Dr, Millersport, OH 43046

Buckeye Lake Winery

For wine enthusiasts, a visit to Buckeye Lake Winery is a must. This scenic winery features a welcoming ambiance, complete with sprawling lakeside views. Sample their handcrafted wines and pair them with delectable appetizers and entrees from their carefully curated menu. Whether you’re a wine connoisseur or simply appreciate a fine glass of vino, Buckeye Lake Winery offers an unforgettable experience.

Best restaurants at Buckeye Lake

When it comes to culinary delights, Buckeye Lake, Ohio, has a lot to offer. From breweries that serve mouthwatering American cuisine to pizzerias that satisfy all cravings, there’s something for every taste bud. So, the next time you find yourself in Buckeye Lake, be sure to visit these fantastic restaurants and indulge in a dining experience that will leave you craving for more. Bon appétit!

Looking for more fun things to do near Buckeye Lake:

17 Charming Things To Do In Lancaster, Ohio

Save This For Later

Where to eat and drink at Buckeye Lake