The 17 Best Restaurants In Richmond Indiana

Looking for the best places to eat during your next visit to Richmond, Indiana?

Are you hungry? Chances are you probably will be later today or tomorrow. When hunger strikes, we are here to answer the perplexing question, “Where should we eat?”, with this list of the best restaurants in Richmond, Indiana.

Whether it is a fine dining experience or a quick breakfast, a casual lunch, or a sweet treat, our list has you covered. Gone are the days of spending hours debating while starvation sets in. Without further ado, here is the list of the Top 17 Restaurants In Richmond, Indiana. 

17 Best Restaurants In Richmond Indiana

Firehouse BBQ & Blues

Situated in the heart of Richmond, this unique BBQ joint is in Richmond’s oldest firehouse! The historic firehouse was transformed into a hub of BBQ greatness and blues by fireman Tom Broyles. 

In addition to fire memorabilia throughout the building, including the original fire pole, the restaurant pays tribute to Richmond’s deep connection to Blues. Richmond, Indiana, is the birthplace of recorded Jazz, and this music legacy is not forgotten. Live music is a common occurrence at Firehouse BBQ & Blues; check their schedule for upcoming performances.

It should go without saying that BBQ is king here. Start your BBQ feast with pulled pork nachos or maybe their smoked wings. Then grab a Smokin Hog (a hot dog stuffed with pulled pork) or one of their signature sandwiches! Not a BBQ fan? There are plenty of menu items to choose from, making this a perfect spot to visit with a family, group, or friends.

Outdoor seating is available, and their patio is a decent size. During warmer weather, tables extend onto the sidewalks to accommodate more outdoor guests.

Be sure to check out these fun Outdoor Things To Do In Richmond, Indiana.

Ullery’s Ice Cream

For the best ice cream in town, stop into Ullery’s Homemade Ice-Cream Parlor. The sweet smells of freshly baked waffle cones drift through the air, making any thoughts of sharing go out the window. You will want your own cone!

The assortment of flavors is incredible, with a section being only seasonal flavors. They offer traditional dairy-free and vegan options. They are also pet-friendly, so be sure to bring your furry friend along for a treat.

Ullery’s is a part of Richmond’s Chocolate Trail. The Chocolate Trail will take guests to the sweetest spots in Richmond. Grab a passport to start your journey!

The Smoothie Shack

Head into Centerville for delicious nutrient-packed smoothies and acai bowls! The Smoothie Shack is next to the beautiful new mural in the heart of Main Street Centerville. The Smoothie Shack is attached to American Wellness, which offers a plethora of natural supplements and services.

Tip: The Smoothie Shack offers a chicken salad on Fridays and Saturdays!

Check out more things to do in Centerville in this Getaway Guide!

Little Sheba’s

This Richmond Staple is right in the heart of Richmond’s Depot District. Little Sheba’s has been serving up family classics for years. With a wide variety of menu items, it is easy for everyone to find their perfect entree. You can’t go wrong with the Sheba Burger and the Gyro! 

The patio area is fenced in with lovely flower beds. 

Galo’s Italian Grill : One Of The Best Italian Restaurants In Richmond, Indiana

For a fine-dining experience, splurge on the best Italian in Richmond with a visit to Galo’s. This locally owned restaurant is giving guests a taste of Italy closer to home with scratch-made dishes. Locals rave about the salmon and steak, while others enjoy splitting a bottle of wine over a pizza.

Galo’s does offer outdoor seating; however, their patio is on the smaller side. Expect a wait if you plan on visiting during peak hours.

Bismarck Donuts

Bismarck Coffee & Donuts is serving fresh-made donuts daily. There is a reason a line is always out the door, and the drive-thru is busy. These heavenly donuts are remarkable. Get there early to get some of their most popular donuts as they sell out fast! Bismarck also offers delicious decorated cookies and can do special orders.

Cordial Cork Restaurant and Wine Bar

The Cordial Cork is a local favorite that has won the hearts of many with exceptional waitstaff, a diverse menu, and a phenomenal wine selection. The historical features of the old building create a neat atmosphere and ambiance. Dive into a plate of the loaded brisket nachos, enjoy a plate of Shrimp Carbonara or bite into Jack’d Up Sammich made of BBQ Jackfruit.

Cap of your evening with a vast bourbon selection, one of their incredible desserts made from the bakery, then return for Brunch that weekend.

The Cordial Cork is a must on any Girlfriend Trip To Richmond, Indiana!

Lumpy’s Cafe

Bite into a giant hand-breaded tenderloin sandwich that is crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Lumpy’s cafe is serving up this signature dish along with other classic breakfast and lunch options. The prices are reasonable, the staff is excellent, and the breakfast is not to be missed at this traditional diner.

Legends Southside Bar and Grill: One Of The Best Restaurants In Richmond Indiana

Wayne County’s oldest tavern and the second oldest in the state of Indiana is Legends. Established in 1858, it goes without saying this place has a fascinating history. They are known for their burgers and pork tenderloin sandwich. I feel that you can’t go wrong with any of the entrees because everything that came out of the kitchen was tempting.

Other recommendations here are the fried pickles and their grill cheese sandwiches. However, keep in mind this isn’t a kid-friendly place as it is a bar, and guests must be over 21 to enter.

RedFront Pizza and Grill

For a causal family-friendly pizza place, pay a visit to RedFront Pizza. This sports bar is serving up made-to-order pizzas, wings, subs, and a variety of craft cocktails. RedFont is a great spot to catch the big game, meet up with friends, or even order pizza to enjoy at home.

A second RedFront Pizza location can be found in New Paris, Ohio, however, it is a smaller location.

Rosco’s Coffee Bar

The place to grab a locally sourced craft coffee is none other than Rosco’s Coffee Bar. This unique dining establishment doesn’t just serve coffee. On the contrary, they also offer a wine and craft beer taproom, in addition to a sandwich shop! It is the ideal spot to start your morning, have an after-work happy hour, or grab a quick lunch!

Old Richmond Inn

One of the most upscale dining experiences in Richmond is at the Old Richmond Inn. Known for their timeless classics, fresh seafood, and tender steaks, this is where you go to celebrate all of life’s many occasions. Everything on the menu consists of fresh ingredients making it difficult to choose just one entree!

The Old Richmond Inn opened up in 1984 in the old Ferdinand Grothaus house that has been around since 1892. The historic character of the old home adds a lovely charm to the restaurant. Reservations are often needed, so make them in advance. 

A.J.’s Diner

For your classic diner staples, swing into A.J.’s Diner. It’s a no-frills, old-time diner with charming brick walls and old-time photographs scattered throughout the restaurant. Servers greet you with a smile, entrees come out quickly, and coffee is always ready.

Jacks Donuts

For freshly handmade donuts swing into Jack’s Donuts in Richmond. In addition to a vast assortment of delicious donuts, they offer various tasty coffee drinks especially ice coffee drinks.

No 9 Grill in Cambridge City

Known for their hand-cut sizzling steaks and juicy hamburgers, the No 9 Grill is one of the best restaurants in Richmond, Indiana. Another popular item is the pork tenderloin, an Indiana Staple! A visit to the No 9 Grill is the perfect way to end an evening of antique shopping.

Grab BBQ Sliders at Stone Hearth Cafe

If you feel peckish while browsing, stop by the Stone Hearth Cafe. Snack on tasty BBQ sliders, or order one of their signature pizzas! Right next to the Stone Hearth Cafe is an excellent collection of Indiana wines and craft beer you can add to your cart.

Fountain Acres Amish Market: One Of The Best To-Go Restaurants In Richmond, Indiana

A little local secret is that the Fountain Acres Amish Market has the best made-to-order deli sandwiches in Richmond. The sandwiches are huge and cheap! During the warm months, people take their sandwiches outside, select a table, and eat their sandwiches.

Fountain Acres Amish Market is an Amish store like no other. Need 10 pounds of homemade fudge, a new gazebo, a beautiful new table, several pounds of potato salad, or a pie? They got you covered.

Did you enjoy our guide to the top restaurants in Richmond, Indiana? If so check out our related posts.

25 Top Things To Do In Richmond, Indiana

10 Reasons To Attend The Richmond Meltdown Ice Festival

A Complete Guide To The Covered Bridges Of Preble County

Pin It For Later

Best Restaurants In Richmond Indiana